Insurance Protection That’s Better, Together

About Us

Providing personal and business insurance solutions in Ohio, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Tennessee, South Carolina, North Carolina, and Texas.

How can we help today?

Personal Insurance

Business Insurance

Insurance Quotes

Chris Arnott Agency, Inc.

Who we are

Our core values are centered around family, exceptional service, and a commitment to ongoing growth and improvement.

As an independent agency, we offer a wide range of options, tailoring insurance solutions to fit your individual needs. We take care of the details, educate you throughout your life’s journey, and focus on your well-being.

When you choose the Chris Arnott Agency, you’re not just getting coverage — you’re gaining a dedicated advocate to guide you through the insurance process with confidence.

Chris Arnott Agency

Community Involvement

Our agency proudly participated in the Game Ready, Life Ready scholarship program with All American Field House, which was awarded to Tatum Olczak! Tatum is a dedicated student-athlete at Plum Senior High and competes on SLAAM Basketball’s AAU team while maintaining an impressive 4.1 GPA.

Pictured here are our Select Commercial Account Team leader, Jenn Brown; Tatum; and All American’s Assistant GM, Lonny.

Congratulations, Tatum! Wishing you the best as you embark on this exciting next chapter.

Scholarship

Our Team of Professionals

At Chris Arnott Agency, Inc., driven by our mission to serve, we work with dedicated specialists to find coverage tailored to your needs. We pride ourselves on exceptional, family-focused service, from policy setup to hands-on support during claims.

Chris Arnott

Agency Owner

Aaron Baaske

Agency Owner

Sue Stefl

Operations Manager/Associate Agent

Jenn Brown

Commercial Operation Manager/Associate Agent

Rob McCoy

Commercial Specialist/Associate Agent

Valerie Kolich

Agency Administrator, Associate Agent

Jane Towery

Associate Agent

Eileen Childers

Associate Agent

Tracy Malarski

Associate Agent

Chrystal McGraw

Associate Agent

Liz Newhouse

CSR/Associate Agent

Dylon Courtney

Master Certified Farm Insurance Agent, Crop Insurance Agent

Bryan Russell

Life/Medicare Specialist

Jessica Grafton

CSR/Associate Agent

Chris Arnott Agency, Inc.

Working with us has it’s advantages

Tailored insurance solutions that understand your community’s needs.

We provide options to find the best coverage at the best price.
We continuously analyze the marketplace to meet your evolving needs.
We stand by you, offering objective advice and support whenever you need it.

Explore your insurance options.

 

Chris Arnott Agency, Inc. offers a wide range of personal and business insurance solutions to residents and businesses across Ohio and beyond. Explore our coverage options and connect with a team member to get a personalized quote today!

All Personal Insurance Info

All Business Insurance Info

Here’s what our clients are saying

Susanne is amazing at what she does! Just recently purchased a new car that ridiculously raised my insurance policy. When I gave her a call to she what she can do. She ended up saving me so much money!

Brittany B., Google Review

We have our house and vehicle insurance with Chris Arnott Agency and Sue and Sarah have always been so very helpful anytime we needed anything, as well the Chris meister, who is a long time friend as well who we really appreciate. They are all extremely knowledgable. Great agency with great prices.

Cheryl R., Google Review

Sue and Sara are great. Always helpful and have great advice when I need it. Give them a call and get a free quote. I did, and am so glad I did. I am so much better off now after switching away from my old company. Give them a call today, you will be glad you did.

Aaron B., Google Review

I really liked that I could pay the premiums for a whole year, including car insurance, with my credit card. There’s a discount for bundles too.

Whenever I had a claim, they were right there to help make the process fast & easy.

Michele D, Google Review

Just started my first policy through the Arnott Agency and I dealt with Sue. She was wonderful! She had almost everything ready for me (that she could) for when I arrived, and the process was quick and easy. Job well done!

Adam B., Google Review

Areas we Service

We work hard to provide tailored coverage options for your community. We’re here to meet your insurance needs across Ohio, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Tennessee, South Carolina, North Carolina, and Texas.

Chris Arnott Agency Logo

Headquarters

16519 St Clair Ave
East Liverpool, OH 43920

Send us a Message!